NDVI says these leaves are healthy. The red edge disagrees.
We photographed 34 grape leaves, healthy to dead, with one 9-camera LATTICE L9 array: twelve narrow bands and a color reference from a single trigger. Pick a layout below, then step through every camera, band and index.
9cameras, one trigger
12narrow bands, 430–958 nm
RGBtrue color, same trigger
34leaves, healthy to dead
The studio setup
One leaf at a time, on a backing that stays black in the infrared
Each leaf lay flat on carbon black foam. Foam that looks black can still glow in the near-infrared; this sheet reads 2–4% from 450 to 940 nm, so it adds almost nothing to the leaf's red edge.
All nine cameras used the wider-angle L87 lens (3.5 mm, 90° across). From 1.0 m, each pixel covers about 1 mm of leaf. Settings stayed fixed for the whole shoot.
A T4P-R125 reflectance target sat beside every leaf, and every band was referenced to its panels in the same frame. A DAQ-E-S light sensor recorded the light.
The layouts further down are simulated: each leaf was captured on its own, with the same height, light and exposures, then placed in a sheet of eight at true relative size.
T4P-R125 reflectance targetDAQ-E-S light sensorLeaf 31The set as the array's own RGB camera saw it, cropped just below the foam: the T4P panel in its case, the DAQ-E-S on the case hinge in the middle of the frame, leaf 31 on the foam.LATTICE arrayHalogen domes and LED floods around the array, in the middle beside the fan.
CamerasLATTICE 9-camera L9 array, every camera with the L87 lens. The modules we chose for this set: six M3M mono (F450, F520, F685, F725, F750, F940) and three M3C color (RGB, RGN, OCN), from the filter options
LightsFour halogen lamps and four RGBW LED lamps, all at full power: about 3,700 K together at the set, measured by the DAQ-E-S
BackingCarbon black foam, 2–4% reflectance from 450 to 940 nm
CaptureChloros, 12-bit, gain 0, all nine cameras on one trigger
AlignmentCalibrated alignment (depth-aware), every band within a fraction of a pixel at the leaf
LATTICE L9The array behind every image on this page: nine M3 cameras in one block, all on one trigger, each with its own filter.See the L9 array
Leaf 19, every band
One trigger, twelve bands plus RGB
Every band the array recorded for leaf 19, in wavelength order. The six mono cameras carry one narrow filter each and the RGN and OCN cameras three each: twelve narrow bands. The RGB camera adds broad blue, green and red, and true color. Values are the leaf's median reflectance (ρ).
Halogen lamps give a smooth spectrum that reaches past 940 nm but little blue; the RGBW LEDs add blue and green and no near-infrared. Together they light every band the array records.
One leaf, three answers
Leaf 31 looks healthy. NDVI agrees. The red edge doesn't.
NDVI compares red with near-infrared. Once a leaf has a fair amount of chlorophyll, red is almost fully absorbed and NDVI flattens out near the top of its scale.
The red edge, the steep climb in reflectance between 700 and 750 nm, keeps moving as chlorophyll falls. For this set we put a 725 nm red-edge camera in the array, one of the filtered modules you can choose for any LATTICE position, so the red-edge chlorophyll index (CIre) can see what NDVI can't.
Your eyeLooks healthy in RGBGreen, no spots or browningNDVI (RGN)0.64Healthy, says NDVIRed edge (CIre)0.12Stressed, says red edge
HealthyStressedDead tissue (no chlorophyll) is drawn red. Each index on its own scale.
Three leaves, eight bands
Leaf 20, healthyLeaf 31, NDVI healthy, red-edge stressedLeaf 27, dead
At 725 nm leaf 31 reflects 0.38 against leaf 20's 0.26: its red edge has moved toward shorter wavelengths, the classic sign of falling chlorophyll. In red (660 nm) the two read 0.09 and 0.06, and in near-infrared (850 nm) 0.42 and 0.35, so NDVI barely moves.
The six mono cameras plus the RGN's red and near-infrared. F940 sits on a water band, so dry tissue reads brighter there.
Explore the set
Eight leaves, every camera
Pick a layout, then a view. Sweep steps through the bands in wavelength order.
Color
Single bands
Indices
Outlined: NDVI says healthy, the red edge says stressed. Dead tissue (no chlorophyll) is drawn red in every index map.
HealthyStressedDead tissue (no chlorophyll) is drawn red. Each index on its own scale.
True colorFRGB camera · white-balanced
The RGB camera, white-balanced on the T4P panels with the camera's own color matrix, then given more exposure (×1.5), local contrast and deconvolution, and enlarged. What your eye sees.
RGN false colorFRGN · 660 / 550 / 850 nm
The RGN camera's own three channels. Near-infrared rides in the blue channel, so leaves with healthy cell structure glow blue.
OCN false colorFOCN · 615 / 490 / 808 nm
Orange, cyan and near-infrared, with near-infrared in blue. A relative map: the OCN's cyan correction was tuned for this set, and its cyan is visibly noisy.
Blue 450M3M F450 · 430–458 nm
Chlorophyll and carotenoids both absorb blue, so every living leaf is dark.
Blue FRGBM3C RGB · 400–506 nm
The color camera's blue channel. Broad and overlapping with its neighbors: a color reference, not a calibrated band.
Cyan 490M3C OCN · 471–509 nm
Cyan, the edge of carotenoid absorption. A relative map on this set; the grain is real sensor noise.
Green 520M3M F520 · 504–536 nm
The rising side of the green peak. Yellowing leaves brighten here first.
Green FRGBM3C RGB · 480–602 nm
The color camera's green channel: a color reference, not a calibrated band.
Green 550M3C RGN · 535–565 nm
The green reflectance peak that makes leaves look green. A relative map on this set.
Orange 615M3C OCN · 604–626 nm
Orange: chlorophyll absorbs strongly, so healthy leaves stay dark and browning ones light up. A relative map on this set.
Red FRGBM3C RGB · 582–662 nm
The color camera's red channel: a color reference, not a calibrated band.
Red 660M3C RGN · 650–670 nm
Red, near chlorophyll's strongest absorption. The red half of NDVI.
Red 685M3M F685 · 675–698 nm
The bottom of the chlorophyll well, just before the red edge begins.
Red edge 725M3M F725 · 712–738 nm
On the red edge itself. Reflectance climbs steeply here, and where it climbs moves with chlorophyll: the band that catches leaf 31.
Red edge 750M3M F750 · 729–763 nm
The top of the red edge, where the leaf turns bright.
NIR 808M3C OCN · 801–815 nm
Near-infrared, the NIR half of OCN NDVI. A relative map on this set.
NIR 850M3C RGN · 835–865 nm
The near-infrared plateau: the leaf's cell structure scatters it back. The NIR half of NDVI and CIre.
NIR 940M3M F940 · 923–958 nm
Far near-infrared, on a water absorption band: dry, brown tissue reads brighter here than green tissue.
NDVI · RGN(NIR 850 − Red 660) / (NIR 850 + Red 660)
The standard vegetation index, from the RGN camera alone. It separates living from dead well, but flattens out on any leaf with a fair amount of chlorophyll.
The same idea from the OCN camera's orange and near-infrared. A relative map on this set.
GNDVI(NIR 850 − Green 520) / (NIR 850 + Green 520)
Green in place of red, from the F520 camera beside the RGN's near-infrared. Green is absorbed less than red, so GNDVI keeps responding a little further up the chlorophyll range.
NDRE(NIR 850 − Red edge 725) / (NIR 850 + Red edge 725)
The normalized red-edge difference. It needs the F725 camera beside the RGN.
Tracks chlorophyll across its whole range, where NDVI flattens. Brown pigment makes a red-edge slope too, which CIre would read as healthy; that is one reason dead tissue is drawn red.
The numbers
Every leaf in the layouts
Median of each leaf's pixels, edge trimmed. Values compare the leaves on this set; they are not field values. CIre values in red are the leaves it rates very stressed while NDVI rates them 0.5 or more.
Leaf
NDVI (RGN)
NDVI (OCN)
GNDVI
NDRE
CIre
Leaf 15deep green
0.74
0.71
0.62
0.14
0.32
Leaf 20deep green
0.72
0.70
0.60
0.14
0.33
Leaf 13green, one browning lobe
0.70
0.62
0.54
0.09
0.20
Leaf 19green
0.67
0.54
0.51
0.07
0.15
Leaf 16green, purpling at the edge
0.64
0.56
0.60
0.11
0.26
Leaf 31pale green
0.64
0.51
0.57
0.06
0.12
Leaf 12green with yellow patches
0.58
0.44
0.51
0.07
0.15
Leaf 25pale olive
0.56
0.41
0.46
0.12
0.27
Leaf 10pale yellow-green
0.51
0.34
0.44
0.04
0.07
Leaf 6yellow and brown blotches
0.47
0.40
0.50
0.08
0.1658% dead tissue
Leaf 22brown
0.45
0.39
0.57
0.08
0.1892% dead tissue
Leaf 24half green, half brown
0.43
0.29
0.43
0.04
0.08
Leaf 21brown
0.34
0.31
0.53
0.08
0.1891% dead tissue
Leaf 29half brown, half dry
0.29
0.35
0.54
0.07
0.1573% dead tissue
Leaf 28dry and brown
0.16
0.23
0.44
0.07
0.15100% dead tissue
Leaf 27dead
0.10
0.11
0.30
0.02
0.04100% dead tissue
All 34 leaves
The whole set, healthy to dead
Every leaf from the shoot on one sheet, at true size relative to each other, in leaf-number order. Switch between true color, NDVI and the red edge to see which leaves each one calls stressed.
StressedHealthyDead tissue (no chlorophyll) is drawn red. Each index on its own scale.
How it was made
Capture to color map
F450F685F940F725FRGBF750FRGNF520FOCNCaptureAll nine cameras fire on one trigger. 12-bit, gain 0, each camera's exposure fixed so nothing clips. Each tile sits where its camera sits in the array, seen from behind, as if looking down on the set over the cameras.
F450F685F940F725FRGBF750FRGNF520FOCNReflectanceEach band is divided by the T4P target's 94% and 50% panels in its own frame, capture by capture, before anything is moved: the leaf still sits a little differently in every camera.
StandardCalibratedRegistrationThen the bands are registered to each other. Standard alignment, one warp per camera, is exact at a single depth; on this shoot it left them a median of 13.7 px apart at the leaf. Calibrated alignment works at the leaf's own depth: 0.15 px, so edges do not fringe.
RGBNDVI · RGNNDVI · OCNGNDVINDRECIreStressedHealthyColor mapsOne red-to-green ramp for every index, green at the healthy end, stretched from the 2nd to the 98th percentile of all 34 leaves. Dead tissue (no chlorophyll, PSRI above 0.10) is drawn red in every index map.